Anna Magdalena Bach- composer?

Anna Magdalena Bach- composer?

Martin Jarvis, professor of music at Charles Darwin University in Australia, claims some of Johann Sebastian Bach’s best-loved works were actually written by his wife. By Hannah Furness.


Forensic analysis of some of Johann Sebastian Bach’s best-loved works proves they were actually written by his wife, an academic has claimed. Martin Jarvis, professor of music at Charles Darwin University in Australia, argues that Anna Magdalena, Bach’s second wife, was actually the composer of some of his major works, including the Cello Suites.

The academic, who first proposed his theory to his sceptical peers in 2006, has spent years compiling evidence, with a comprehensive study of handwriting and manuscripts.

A new documentary will now detail the analysis of ink and writing style to “prove” Mrs Bach had far more input than previously thought. Presented by Sally Beamish, a British composer, and due to be screened at Bafta next week, the film will include evidence from an American forensic scientist who analysed the composer’s signature and his famous scores.

Prof Jarvis said he aims to overturn the “sexist” convention that recognised composers were always a “sole male creator”, to finally reinstate Mrs Bach into the history books.

I find this all very interesting. It does seem that Anna Magdalena was a talented woman, and  worked alongside J.S Bach, who in his later years had failing  eye sight. She was clearly of great assistance to him in writing out the scores- but did she compose herself? It’s great that it is actually a man (Martin Jarvis) who is seeking for a woman musician to recognised! It certainly is strange that Anna Magdalena’s portrait went missing (destroyed?) and also many of the Bach manuscripts after her passing.

Read on:

Another article on Anna Magdalena:

Anna Magdalena Bach: a forgotten genius? If JS Bach’s wife composed some of his best-known pieces, it will put a bomb at the heart of the Western musical tradition. By Ivan Hewett.

So, the shocking truth is out. Anna Magdalena Bach, second wife of the great J.S Bach, was more than just the humble copyist of her husband’s music. She actually composed some of it.

This is the theory of two music-loving members of the Association of Forensic Document Examiners. They’ve pored over the handwriting in a number of Bach’s manuscripts, and concluded that some pieces copied by Anna Magdalena don’t show the proper hallmarks of the copyists’ style. The handwriting isn’t deliberate or “heavy” enough. It’s the quick uncertain hand of someone thinking and creating as they write. They reckon that among the pieces Anna Magdalena composed herself are the Cello Suites and the 1st Prelude and Fugue from the Well-Tempered Clavier.

It’s an astonishing revelation, but is it true? A stylistic feature of handwriting seems a slender basis for re-attributing some of Bach’s best-known pieces. We want some corroborating evidence, and that’s not so easy to find. We know Anna Magdalena played the harpsichord, not least because her husband wrote his famous collection of easy pieces called the “Little Notebook” for her to play. We know she was musically literate, as she acted as his copyist. But there isn’t a single hint in the surviving documents of the Bach household that she may have composed music. And frankly, how could she have done, with a large household to run? Also she would have had to defy one of the strongest prejudices of her era. This held that Woman, a lesser sort of being made from Adam’s spare rib, couldn’t possibly be creative. She could sing and play music, but only men could do the serious intellectual business of writing the stuff.

However there’s another way of looking at the evidence. In those days the divisions between performance, improvisation and composing weren’t sharp. Composing arose naturally out of improvising, and improvising would have been part of any musician’s training. So in her quiet moments, when Anna Magdalena had time to play, it’s likely she would have made up pieces, and even written them down. Perhaps the reason no one in her circle mentioned this is that it was considered a slightly indecent occupation for a woman. And Anna Magdalena herself, being a proper Leipzig hausfrau, wouldn’t have advertised the fact.

Read on:

Cellist Steven Isserlis debunks the claim:

Suite scandal: why Bach’s wife cannot take credit for his cello masterwork.

Why are people so credulous when it comes to classical music? A film called Written by Mrs Bach has just appeared, followed by various breathless press reports, all seeming to give it credence. The film claims that Johann Sebastian Bach’s 6 Suites for solo cello, among the greatest, and most beloved, pieces of music ever written, were in fact composed by Bach’s second wife, Anna Magdalena. This “theory” was first propounded some years ago by Martin Jarvis, a professor at Charles Darwin University in Northern Territory, Australia, who is at the centre of this new film. The theory got some attention, was dismissed by Bach scholars and then (I thought) died forever; but here it is again.

Professor Jarvis is a charming and sincere man – I met him then to talk it over. But I’m afraid that his theory is pure rubbish. Anna Magdalena Bach did not write the Bach suites, any more than Anne Hathaway wrote Shakespeare’s plays, George Henry Lewes wrote George Eliot’s novels, or Freddie Starr ate his friend’s hamster.

Read on:

Personally, I don’t find it so incredible that Anna Magdalena was able to compose music! I’d welcome some comments!


2 thoughts on “Anna Magdalena Bach- composer?

  1. I don’t find the idea of Anna Magdalena composing some of these works so incredible, either, nor the idea that she and her family might have hidden the fact. But I really have no opinion one way or the other because I am not enough of a Bach scholar to analyze the works in question to show that the same person did or did not write all of them.

    Surely Anna Magdalena’s musical thinking must have influenced Johann Sebastian’s in some way, since they lived and worked closely together.

    It seems much more incredible to me that this lady managed to bear and care for so many children, including a developmentally disabled one if I remember correctly, and to deal with probably a rather cantankerous husband. Even more incredible is the fact that her family allowed her to fall into poverty at the end of her life.

    (By the way, almost anyone OTHER than William Shakespeare the actor seems more likely as the author of “his” works, since he himself is such an implausible candidate. There are some strong reasons to think that the Shakespeare opus was written by a woman.)

  2. Thanks for your thoughtful comments Elene. I find it more incredible how she managed to bear so many children- 13 wasn’t it, than she composed music! Goodness me imagine going through that 13 times in those days. She must have been strong to survive it.
    I have heard about the possibility that William Shakespeare didn’t write his plays alone- that they were collaborative efforts. I don’t know enough to have an opinion on that, nor about Anna Magdalena and J.S Bach either, but in the second article the writer makes some points that the style is rather unusual in some of the works which is a case for Anna being the composer.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s